The Best & Most Comfortable Crib Mattress of 2022 (Updated March ’22)

best crib mattresses

After testing many crib mattresses from the leading manufacturers, we found Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress as a perfect option if you are tight on budget and needs a highly efficient bed for your baby.

Contents [hide]

A high-quality baby crib mattress helps a child with a cozy sleep throughout the night and enhances healthy growth along with safety. Babies and toddlers spend their time in a sleeping environment of any sort. Usually, the newborn babies sleep more than 16 hours a day whereas a child 3-5 years old sleep an average of 11-13 hours. Therefore, it’s essential to have their surroundings and beddings better than anything.

You will find numerous crib mattress brands and products on the market but be choosing the right one can be pretty challenging. That’s why we have shortlisted the best five baby crib mattresses for you. To provide you with general information, we included an essential buying guide. Our chosen top 5 reviews and detailed analysis of significant factors will assist you to make the best choice.


Best Overall Crib Mattress
Best Organic Crib Mattress
Best Mini Crib Mattress
Best Eco Friendly Mattress
Safety 1st
Best Eco Friendly Mattress


View On Amazon


The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core mattress is among the best beds for babies around the world. These mattresses have won Women’s choice award in the year 2013 and 2014.

The mattress is not double sided, yet it provides your kid with a firm and comfortable sleeping surface. The high density along with added cotton cushioning keeps the product well balanced. The pear engraved cover is 100% waterproof and stain-resistant which is a huge plus when it comes to cleanliness and maintenance. Further, the hypoallergenic foam is CertiPUR-US® certified and engineered with using soybean oils thus making it a healthy option to consider.

The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core mattress comes with a square cornered design for added safety and quality for a perfect snug. It’s an efficient and highly usable choice for anyone who is looking to purchase a quality product.


View on Amazon


The Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic is a top quality organic mattress from one of the renowned manufacturers in the organic mattress field.

The GOTS certified producer successfully meets the Green Guard certification standards for chemical and allergens emission removal. This crib mattress has got quite famous in no time for providing a natural, healthy and comfortable sleep to babies and toddlers. It’s a double sided mattress offering a firm infant side and another softer side for toddlers.

It features waterproof edges along with 150 coils and edge support to enhance its strength and keeps it easy to maintain. The product is made from 100% organic cotton with an easy to clean eco-friendly waterproof surface. Though this is not the cheapest mattress, as a natural option this really sets a standard.


View On Amazon


The Milliard Hypoallergenic Mini Crib Mattress is an excellent model that features a waterproof cover. The hypoallergenic baby crib mattress makes it an ideal option for a newborn.

The interior of the mattress is constructed from foam which makes sure to provide optimum comfort to your baby. This foam filling is capable of keeping the mattress firm yet comfortable. The foam filling keeps the mattress reinforced with a waterproof covering which is made of a breathable material. Further, the optimal airflow regulates the baby’s temperature while sleeping.

The encasement comes with a dark blue fabric along with polka dots pattern which makes it highly appealing for both boys and girls. Finally, the mattress is engineered with antimicrobial and anti-allergens which is an ideal option for babies suffering from asthma or sensitivities.


View On Amazon


If you have a limited budget and still looking for a quality mattress, the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress can be the best choice.

The mattress comes with notable features to keep your baby’s skin protected. It is made of hypoallergenic materials so your babies can have a relaxing sleep without getting affected from rashes and skin irritations. The use of high-density fiber core gives the mattress superior support and balance to keep your baby in comforting position. The lightweight and heavy-duty mattresses are capable of withstanding bouncing without bending.

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress grows with your child which makes it a smart investment. The vinyl cover is fully waterproof for easy maintenance. Lastly, this model is GREENGUARD GOLD certified thus becoming a safe and healthy option to give your baby some beautiful dreams.

View On Amazon


The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress is a dual foam mattress. The model has achieved tremendous popularity for its medical grade built and lightweight which helps in mid-night sheet changes.

The mattress does not feature any chemical and low-grade materials thus making it an eco-friendly and safe product. It’s a plant-based mattress which means it incorporates healthy plant oils instead of petroleum-based oils for minimum harmful air emissions. Featuring a lightweight of 9.3 lbs, it comes with a certified organic cotton cover with a waterproof backing.

It offers your baby a fine cloth to sleep on and the waterproof backing which prevent anything to seep in. Overall, it’s a healthy option for parents to keep their child sleep in a comfortable and natural setting.





The foam crib mattresses are engineered with polyurethane which is a popular choice for many parents and are relatively inexpensive compared to innerspring and organic mattresses. They are available in a variety of depths, and the most popular ones are between 3 and 6 inches. Also, they are lightest in weight which lets you quickly clean the baby mess and change the sheets. Most polyurethane mattresses weigh less than innerspring. A regular polyurethane mattress comes with the approximate weight of 7-8 pounds.


An innerspring crib mattress is more expensive than the polyurethane models; still, they remain incredibly popular. They provide an appropriate firm level of support offered by the coil which makes them an excellent choice for orthopedic comfort and safety.


From the price point, the organic crib mattresses are expensive than the above two options. However, the price is worth investing. These models are environmentally safe and 100% organic which eliminates the potentially hazardous substances and allergens. These elements can be more severe if your child is prone to allergies. Remember that your child will be in close contact with the mattress on a regular basis, so it’s crucial to consider the long-term hazards when using other traditional mattresses instead of good organic models.


A mattress must fit snugly in the crib. It should not have any space between the side of the mattress and the crib frame. If there is some space, it means the mattress is smaller than the required size that can be both suffocating and unsafe for your child. Usually, crib mattress comes with a standard size as stated by the federal government. However, due to little variations, not every mattress can fit perfectly to a particular crib.


Comfort is the leading factor for a toddler’s sleep. When your baby is old enough to get often disturbed while sleeping, this is the time where the comfort category comes in. Here dual sided mattress can be the best solution or those models that can be used on both sides. If your child wants a transition onto a more comfortable side, all you need to do is just flip it over. These mattresses quickly adjust to the child increasing weight and provide them with excellent comfort.


The firmer crib mattress is a suitable option for babies and toddlers. Even if they are stiff, your baby will get used to it with the passage of time. To check the firmness of a mattress, press on the center and edges of a bed and it should snap back instead of conforming to the shape of your hand.


If you want high density, your mattress should be firm enough to keep your baby safe and comfortable while sleeping. Many foam mattresses do not specify the density on the packaging. However, weight can help you in indicating the density of the particular model. Usually, the innerspring mattresses often associate the number of coils with firmness. At the same time gauge of the wire is also an important consideration. A lower gauge will give a thicker wire which is firm and robust. You can consider mattresses with 140 or more coils and a gauge of 16 or lower.


Resilience refers to pushing your hand in the center of the mattress and see how quickly it will regain its shape. The faster a mattress regain its form, the better it will function. The sleeping babies often create an impression on the foam, and if the beds retain their shape, it can be uncomfortable for them to sleep. In this case, 2 stage and dual firmness mattresses are an excellent choice as they offer both a firm and soft side for babies.


A traditional foam mattress weighs around 7-8 pounds. Though, mattresses constructed from memory foam weighs about 20 pounds. The innerspring crib mattresses are usually bulky and weigh almost 15-25 pounds. Keep in mind that you will lift only the side of the bed or the entire thing when changing the baby’s sheet.


If you are looking for a water resistance feature, consider double or triple laminated coating reinforced with nylon. This composition will make your mattress resistant to holes, tears, and diapers. Organic mattresses generally come with cotton covers. However, many parents want to consider a fitted waterproof mattress cover for convenience.


It’s important to have some small holes in the mattress that let the air flow in and out. A bed will be more comfortable and smell free if it has sufficient holes to allow odors escape. Diaper leak resistance is also a crucial consideration.


Most standard mattresses recommend spot cleaning only. Some models come with the removable covers that are machine washable. It’s essential to have at least one side of the mattress machine washable or can be cleaned in the tub once the cover is removed.


What if your child is sleeping under the blanket and temperature of the room gets hot? Probably, they will start sweating due to overheating which is a prominent cause of SIDS. Therefore, the breathability of the mattresses is a serious concern. You will find a lot of manufacturers boasting that their beds offer temperature regulation features, but not many of them are right. To test this feature, we took a heating sock and calculated the time it takes to get down to an average body temperature from a temperature of 130 degrees on the mattress. Most breathable mattresses took around 20-25 seconds to get the temperature at regular. We also found that mattresses that are manufactured from cloth tend to retain more heat than the models made from vinyl.


Usually, mattresses made of cloth type does not come with a removable cover which makes it quite difficult to clean compared to those featuring vinyl covers. Removal covers come as handy, and thus they are easy to clean and replace. Further, the vinyl covers are a popular choice as the liquid does not penetrate through the material to let you clean them with minimal effort using a sponge and soap.


When it comes to deciding the best crib mattresses, you really need to consider all the options, features and models available on the market. What suits you may not be appropriate for someone else. Therefore, it’s crucial to consider essential aspects as mentioned in the buying guide to make a right choice that suits you in every aspect whether it is about size, cover, maintenance, budget, comfort and so on. We hope that our crib mattress reviews will help you towards making a perfect choice to serve your baby in the long run.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *